Differential Op-Amp vs. Transconductance Op-Amp Feedback

Hello QSpice and SMPS aficionados,

I have a question regarding which is preferred when selecting the op-amp compensator type between the following two op-amp feedback options:

1.Differential
2. Transconductance

Is selecting the type arbitrary, a rule-of-thumb or perhaps does it depend on the SMPS topology? How do you approach this? Is this critical or not?

Any insight would be appreciated.

Thank you.

The first question is better for whom? For the IC designer and semi manufacturer the transconductance amp saves a pin, usually saves a bit of silicon and is easy to implement.

For the user of the IC, it’s also easy to place 2-3 components from a pin to ground, but what’s often missing is the min and max transconductance of the amplifier. They can often vary by 20-30%. That means you have to have plenty of gain margin to cover the loop gain variation due to just the gm amp, and you can’t really know your worst-case. So not better from that viewpoint. With a differential closed-loop compensator you have enough gain that the external R and C component variation is typically all that you have to worry about (unless the GBW is low).

So either approach works, as long as you know the pitfalls. I prefer the op-amp compensator over the gm amp, for the reasons stated above.

2 Likes

Thank you for responding to my query and lending some wisdom. :slightly_smiling_face:

Yes, this is one of the main reasons that I was asking. I was reviewing the LM5155x controller by TI. The IC implements the compensator by way of a transconductance amplifer. So does another controller by Analog Designs. I forget which IC in particular for that one - I was browsing. However, it led me to the following article titled:

Understand Power Supply Loop Stability and Loop Compensation - Part 3: Loop Design in Three Simple Steps by Henry Zhang, ADI Fellow.

In this paper, the transconductance implementation method was emphasized. However, the majority of papers / app notes that I have come across generally emphasize the op-amp method. So was just asking for clarification.

Fair enough.

Thank you!